For the revolution and transition period to be truly successful, the Tunisian government must both pass and implement constitutional guarantees and legal reforms enshrining and safeguarding freedom of expression, association and the independence of the judiciary, says a new report by the International Freedom of Expression Exchange Tunisia Monitoring Group (IFEX-TMG). The IFEX-TMG is a coalition of 21 IFEX members that has been monitoring free expression violations in Tunisia since 2004.
This final report, Spring into Winter? Fragile achievements and exceptional challenges for Tunisian free expression defenders, will be shared with the Minister of Human Rights and Transitional Justice, Samir Dilou, as well as Constitutional Assembly members at meetings this week. It serves to briefly outline the status of freedom of expression and association as well as the independence of the judiciary.
“Freedom of expression is not a privilege, it is a fundamental right that Tunisians have fought for and earned. The achievement of this right and others seem to be increasingly compromised by uncertainty, inaction and obstruction and the IFEX-TMG is calling on the government to reverse that trend and to resolutely commit to reforms,” says Virginie Jouan, Chair of the IFEX-TMG.
The report outlines the status of free expression in the country, delineates the legal and structural reforms to the media sector, which have taken shape after the revolution, and suggests further steps needed to empower the media to play a role in consolidating democracy.
The report also outlines the improved status of freedom of association in Tunisia as well as the practical obstacles newly-founded NGOs and associations are facing.
Finally, it reviews the critical issue of judicial reform in Tunisia after decades of being subject to intervention by the executive branch of government. It describes the reforms that have already been enacted as well as the ongoing campaign by judges and associations sidelined during the Ben Ali era for a judiciary that would serve as an independent authority.
In a detailed set of recommendations, the report outlines the work required by the transitional government and the constitutional assembly to safeguard free expression, association and the independence of the judiciary. The most immediate concerns include:
- Guarantee freedom of expression, media independence and access to information, including online, in the Constitution, including the independence of public service media and that of the High Authority for Information and Audiovisual Communication (HAICA). The principles of equality and non-discrimination in exercising freedom of expression must be recognised and prior censorship, licensing or registration system for the print media, individual journalists should be prohibited.
- Support a legal and institutional framework that allows the emergence of a media landscape in step with the political, economic and social challenges facing Tunisia and capable of supporting the emergence of free and independent media, supported by an independent judiciary.
- Initiate the drafting a broadcasting law, to complement the HAICA law, with the aim of strengthening the legal framework for licensing, spectrum assignment, content regulation and media diversity and pluralism.
- Dismantle the complex system of censorship established under Ben Ali and prevent its resurgence especially in the name of morality, including through proposed blasphemy laws.
- Decriminalise press offenses while strengthening adherence to journalistic ethics and promoting self-regulation.
- Adopt a comprehensive law on access to information to address the shortfalls of Decree 2011-54 including the absence of clear mechanisms to facilitate access such as an independent oversight body.
- Enshrine freedom of association and the right to assemble in the constitution.
- Establish an institutional framework which would allow regular consultation and collaboration between state actors and civil society organisations.
- Safeguard judicial independence under the Constitution, including promoting mechanisms that will shield the judges from the pressure of the executive branch, in their appointment, discipline and assignment to cases, and that does not give to the executive branch a decisive power over the career path of sitting judges.
Download the full report, Spring into Winter? Fragile achievements and exceptional challenges for Tunisian free expression defenders, here:
- IFEX Tunisia Monitoring Group
- Arabic Network for Human Rights Information
- ARTICLE 19
- Bahrain Center for Human Rights
- Cairo Institute for Human Rights Studies
- Canadian Journalists for Free Expression
- Cartoonists Rights Network International
- Egyptian Organization for Human Rights
- Freedom House
- Index on Censorship
- International Federation of Journalists
- International Federation of Library Associations and Institutions
- International Press Institute
- International Publishers Association
- Journaliste en danger (JED)
- Maharat Foundation (Skills Foundation)
- Media Institute of Southern Africa
- Norwegian PEN
- World Association of Community Radio Broadcasters (AMARC)
- World Association of Newspapers and News Publishers (WAN-IFRA)
- World Press Freedom Committee
- Writers in Prison Committee, PEN International
This post is also available in: Arabic